Supply side lessons from France

France has seen an unprecedented level of capital flight in recent months. The cause - the heavy taxes proposed for high earners by President Hollande. Profit and company payroll taxes are already very high in France and the 75% proposed income tax rate seems to have pushed many to move their money.

The Daily Telegraph article shows the extent of the flight but there are important lessons to be learned.

Many people in the UK have doubted the wisdom of cutting the 50% income tax rate to 45%. There is a feeling that it is 'fair' for the rich to pay more than the middle income earners. This may actually be a reasonable point, but the argument is that the disincentive effects of high tax reduce overall economic performance and so make everyone worse off in the long run. While 75% is a lot more than 50% in tax terms there seems to be credible evidence that incentives do matter.

France has been incredibly slow to adopt supply-side reforms. The French industrialist Louis Gallois has delivered a report calling for 'shock therapy' to help improve French competitiveness. His plan includes cutting payroll taxes for employers, spending cuts and higher consumer taxes. There seems little political will to do this. Hollande is an old fashioned socialist who has no experience of government and ideals are yet to be overcome by reality for him. France carries some of the highest labour costs in the world and with a rapidly expanding trade deficit and 27% youth unemployment the Gallois Report may be the thing that comes back to haunt him at the next election.

A further important point to note is the fall in the French money supply that has resulted from the capital flight. This is potentially serious as it represents a deflationary force in an economy already in recession. Falling money supply is going to reduce AD and prevent recovery. In situations like these deflation is the last thing the economy needs and so the French cannot ignore the loss of confidence the capital flight represents. Like so many socialist leaders before him Hollande must realise that it is not possible for a country to be the sole master of its economic policy.

The Telegraph explains the crisis here

Reuters reports Gallois proposals here

France pays the price for not reforming

There is one consolation for the UK in the recession. It is worse in France.

The French government have just issued their latest budget proposals. This is against a background of three quarters of recession and unemployment of 10.2%. Also the French government budget deficit is significantly higher than it needs to be to meet Euro area rules.

So the French are proposing a 75% tax rate for the really high earners. There is also a new 45% tax rate for those earning more than £120k.

This has an obvious effect on income distribution and that suits the new socialist administration (the LibDem's have similar ideas in the UK). But many say that the French have again missed the point.

The French have resisted making the supply-side reforms which have helped other economies, like the UK, adjust working conditions in the face of the crisis. French employment law continues to discourage firms from employing staff on a permanent basis and raises the cost of employment further beyond the wage rate making employing staff expensive.

The rise in profit taxes makes the prospects for employment worse not better.

The French are caught in a difficult situation. They want to help ease the recession and help the poor and unemployed, but they are finding it hard to make the tough decisions.

The Independent covers the new French budget here